Sam Raimi's A SIMPLE PLAN takes audiences on a chilling descent into greed and moral decay, underscored by a haunting sense of inevitability that is equal parts tragedy and thriller. Adapted from Scott B. Smith's novel by the author, the film is a stark departure from Raimi’s usual dynamic horror fare, revealing a new layer of sophistication to the director's toolkit. Here, Raimi exercises restraint, trading his signature freneticism for a measured approach that illuminates and amplifies the story's psychological darkness.
Set in a small, frozen Midwestern town, A SIMPLE PLAN follows Hank Mitchell (Bill Paxton), his dim-witted brother Jacob (Billy Bob Thornton), and their friend Lou (Brent Briscoe) as they stumble upon a crashed plane in the woods containing over four million dollars in cash. What begins as an idle curiosity quickly shifts to a life-altering opportunity. The men are tempted to keep the money, reasoning that no one would ever know — a plan that initially seems simple enough. However, the ethical compromise of such a choice unravels all three, turning friends into foes and brothers into adversaries in a narrative that feels as inevitable as it is horrifying.
The film’s title belies the spiraling complexity of the events that ensue. A SIMPLE PLAN is anything but simple; rather, it’s a morality tale that explores the fracturing of human relationships under the weight of deception, greed, and escalating violence. The screenplay deftly examines how each character rationalizes his actions, creating a feeling of tension and impending disaster. Smith’s writing — taut, methodical, and disturbingly plausible — never allows the audience to lose sight of the moral erosion at play, even as the plot twists pile on.
Bill Paxton, often cast as the everyman, is ideal here as Hank Mitchell. His performance is as cold and relentless as the snow-covered landscape around him, subtly transforming from the amiable townie with a steady job and moral center into a man consumed by fear and self-preservation. Paxton carefully restrains Hank’s journey toward moral bankruptcy, capturing the disorientation and creeping paranoia of a man who finds himself in over his head. Paxton’s performance is a tightrope act, walking a delicate line between the ordinary and the monstrous, making his eventual descent all the more chilling.
But it’s Billy Bob Thornton as Jacob who delivers the standout performance. As Hank’s socially awkward and childlike older brother, Thornton gives Jacob a sensitivity and naiveté that is both endearing and tragic. His hunched posture, darting eyes, and hesitant speech all speak to a lifetime of pain and frustration, making him the film's emotional heart. Jacob’s vulnerabilities and insecurities create a compelling counterpoint to Hank’s increasing ruthlessness, with Thornton’s portrayal bringing an unsettling pathos to the role. It is in Jacob that we find the story’s true casualty, a man out of his depth who, despite his simplicity, perceives the moral quagmire more acutely than anyone else.
Bridget Fonda, as Hank’s wife Sarah, gives a quietly menacing performance that is as icy as the Minnesota winter. Sarah begins as the voice of reason, advising caution when Hank initially tells her about the money. However, her support for Hank's plan shifts disturbingly as she becomes complicit in his decisions, displaying a sharp pragmatism and cunning that rival Hank's own. Fonda's transformation from skeptical spouse to Machiavellian conspirator is unnerving, portraying Sarah as someone who recognizes the opportunity for a better life and is unafraid to grasp it, whatever the cost.
The aesthetic choices in A SIMPLE PLAN are critical to its atmosphere, with Raimi using the bleak, wintry landscape as both a metaphor and a visual anchor for the narrative's downward spiral. The film's palette is dominated by whites, grays, and cold blues, effectively turning the snowy landscape into a vast, unyielding prison. Cinematographer Alar Kivilo captures the barrenness of the landscape with a meticulous eye, underscoring the isolation and hopelessness of the characters as their world closes in around them. The constant snow and icy air become characters in their own right, reinforcing the film’s themes of entrapment and moral desolation.
Danny Elfman’s restrained score marks another departure from his typically grandiose compositions. Here, he opts for minimalism, using subdued strings and slow, ominous undertones to complement the film’s tense narrative. The score underscores the chilling fatalism of Hank’s choices, adding an auditory layer that captures the impending tragedy without overwhelming the film’s quieter, more psychological moments.
Raimi, known for his kinetic camerawork and feverish pace in films like THE EVIL DEAD and DARKMAN, instead adopts a patient, almost clinical style here, allowing tension to build in stillness. His restrained direction focuses intently on the human faces and emotions in play, forgoing his trademark flourishes in favor of letting the characters and their conflicts breathe and evolve. Raimi seems to recognize that the horror in A SIMPLE PLAN is less about violence and more about the emotional degradation wrought by unchecked avarice.
A SIMPLE PLAN stands as a powerful exploration of moral ambiguity, far removed from the director’s previous work yet fully realizing his skill in evoking terror — this time of the existential variety. In focusing on the psychological unraveling of its characters rather than shock or gore, Raimi proves himself a director of considerable versatility. This somber thriller is not only a meditation on the fragility of morality but also a cautionary tale about the seduction of easy money and the ultimate cost of greed. The film leaves audiences with a lingering sense of dread, reflecting on the lengths people will go to protect what they think they deserve and the irreparable damage they inflict upon themselves and others along the way.
A SIMPLE PLAN is a slow-burning masterpiece of small-town noir, crafting a story that echoes long after the credits roll. Anchored by outstanding performances from its cast, especially Thornton’s vulnerable and haunting turn as Jacob, Raimi’s understated yet chilling approach makes this film a standout exploration of the human condition. It's a film that, in its simplicity, holds a chilling mirror up to the complexity of human nature.
This Blu-ray edition offers a fantastic 4K remaster approved by Sam Raimi himself, delivering the film in stunning 2160p with Dolby Vision HDR10 compatibility. For the audiophiles both the original DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround audio and a lossless stereo option are available.
Bonus features are extensive, with two new audio commentaries from critics and filmmakers, fresh interviews with cinematographer Alar Kivilo and actors Becky Ann Baker and Chelcie Ross, plus archival on-set interviews with stars like Bill Paxton and Billy Bob Thornton. Rounding out the extras are behind-the-scenes footage, the original theatrical trailer, a reversible sleeve with new artwork, and an illustrated booklet featuring essays by film critics.
Overall, this edition is a must-have for collectors, providing a definitive look at Raimi’s film through pristine visuals and a wealth of insightful extras. You can save 50% of the retail price if you order from MVD!!!!