Few films in Al Pacino’s career have been as controversial as Cruising (1980). Directed by William Friedkin, best known for The French Connection (1971) and The Exorcist (1973), Cruising is a psychological thriller that explores the underground leather and S&M subculture of New York City in the late 1970s. The film was met with strong backlash from LGBTQ+ activists upon its release, who feared it perpetuated negative stereotypes about gay men. At the same time, it was a commercial curiosity due to Pacino’s involvement and Friedkin’s track record. Four decades later, Cruising remains a complex and fascinating artifact of its time.
The film follows Steve Burns (Al Pacino), a young and ambitious NYPD officer tasked with going undercover in the gay leather bar scene to catch a serial killer targeting gay men. Burns, who is in a relationship with Nancy (Karen Allen), immerses himself in the subculture and soon finds his identity and sense of morality challenged. As he delves deeper, the lines between his role as a cop and his psychological transformation blur, leading to an ambiguous and unsettling conclusion.
Pacino delivers a nuanced performance, portraying Burns as both determined and increasingly disoriented. Unlike his more iconic roles in The Godfather or Serpico, where his characters exude confidence or charisma, Burns is deliberately subdued, an observer rather than a typical action hero. His descent into moral ambiguity is portrayed through subtle changes in body language and facial expressions rather than overt dramatics. However, the character’s arc is somewhat underdeveloped, leaving audiences with more questions than answers about Burns' internal struggles.
Supporting performances, particularly from Paul Sorvino as Burns’ superior officer and Karen Allen as his girlfriend, are competent but underutilized. The most striking performances come from the actors who populate the underground club scenes, many of whom were non-professional actors cast directly from the scene. Their presence lends an air of authenticity that makes the film’s atmosphere feel raw and immersive.
Friedkin’s direction is both a strength and a source of frustration. The film is undeniably effective at creating tension and unease, particularly through sound design, dark cinematography, and fragmented editing. The frequent use of disorienting visual motifs, such as flashing neon lights and shadowy corridors, helps to establish an eerie, dreamlike quality.
The film’s most compelling aspect is its depiction of the underground leather bars, which Friedkin captures with a documentary-like authenticity. These sequences have a voyeuristic quality, allowing viewers to experience the world through Burns’ eyes. However, the film does not attempt to provide insight into the community it depicts, leaving it open to accusations of sensationalism.
One of Friedkin’s most controversial decisions was to use real members of the leather scene and film in actual clubs, which added to the film’s sense of realism but also contributed to the outcry from LGBTQ+ activists. The film’s refusal to clarify whether Burns undergoes a sexual awakening or remains a detached observer adds to its ambiguity but also leaves gaps in character development.
At its core, Cruising is a film about identity, repression, and the thin line between hunter and prey. Burns’ journey into the leather scene becomes less about law enforcement and more about self-discovery, though the film never fully commits to this theme. The central mystery—who is the killer?—is secondary to the psychological transformation Burns undergoes, but the film does not provide a clear resolution. The final act, including the infamous ambiguous ending, leaves viewers questioning Burns' mental state and the true nature of the crimes.
The film also explores themes of institutional homophobia and police corruption, though in a more subtle manner. The NYPD is depicted as indifferent to the plight of the gay community, using Burns as a tool to infiltrate a world they neither understand nor respect. The casual brutality displayed by law enforcement toward gay men is evident, but Cruising stops short of making an explicit statement about the systemic issues at play.
Upon its release, Cruising faced intense protests from LGBTQ+ activists, who accused the film of reinforcing harmful stereotypes about gay men as hypersexual and prone to violence. Activist groups such as the Gay Liberation Front organized demonstrations, and production was frequently disrupted. Many within the LGBTQ+ community feared that the film would further marginalize an already oppressed group, particularly in the early days of the AIDS crisis.
Friedkin defended his work, arguing that the film was not intended as an indictment of the gay community but rather as a psychological thriller with a unique setting. However, the lack of a clear message and the film’s failure to humanize its gay characters beyond their roles in the club scenes made it difficult for audiences to separate artistic intention from perceived exploitation.
Despite the controversy, Cruising has been re-evaluated in recent years. Some contemporary critics and scholars view it as an unintentional time capsule, preserving a pre-AIDS era of gay subcultures that was rarely depicted in mainstream cinema. Others argue that the film’s ambiguity and refusal to provide easy answers make it more complex than its initial reception suggested.
Cruising is an undeniably fascinating film. While it might fail to fully develop some characters or make a clear thematic statement, it remains a compelling thriller due to its atmosphere, Pacino’s performance, and Friedkin’s taut direction. The film’s controversial reputation is not entirely undeserved, but it might be overstated. It skirts the line between representation and exploitation without ever committing to either, and that's by design.
4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Limited Edition Contents
- Brand new 4K restoration from the original 35mm camera negative by Arrow Films
- 120-page perfect-bound collector’s book featuring articles from The Village Voice and The New York Times, essays from the film’s extras cast, an introduction from William Friedkin, and an archive interview with Al Pacino
- Reversible sleeve featuring original and newly commissioned artwork by Sister Hyde
DISC ONE FEATURE & EXTRAS (4K ULTRA HD):
- 4K (2160p) Ultra HD Blu-ray presentation in Dolby Vision (HDR10 compatible)
- Original lossless English mono audio, 2.0 stereo, and 5.1
- Optional English subtitles for the deaf and hard of hearing
- Two archive audio commentaries by director William Friedkin
- Brand new commentary featuring original musicians involved with the soundtrack
- I Want to Be the Curator, a brand-new interview with actress Karen Allen
- Deleted scenes and alternative footage
- On-set audio featuring the club scenes and protest coverage
- Censored material reels
- Theatrical trailer, teasers, and TV spots
DISC TWO EXTRAS (BLU-RAY):
- Interviews with cast and crew, including Randy Jurgensen, Bud S. Smith, Jay Acovone, and more
- Breaking the Codes, a brand-new visual essay on the hanky-code
- Archival featurettes on the film’s origins, production, and controversies
- Extensive image gallery featuring international promotional material and on-set sketches
For modern audiences, Cruising reminds them of a pivotal moment in cinema and LGBTQ+ history. It challenges, unsettles, and provokes discussion, making it an essential, if problematic, piece of 1980s filmmaking. Whether viewed as an artistic misstep, an underrated thriller, or an invaluable cultural document, Cruising continues to demand attention decades after its release.
You can currently save 15% off the retail price if you order from MVD